The decisions below come from the Puerto Rico Court of Appeals (Tribunal de Apelaciones) and the U.S. District Court for the District of Puerto Rico. Each summary states what the court actually decided, including cases where the trustee won or the claim never reached the merits.
1. The Detroit Bank and Trust Co. v. The Trust Company of the Virgin Islands, Ltd.
Court: U.S. District Court for the District of Puerto Rico (Laffitte, J.) · Date: June 7, 1985 · Docket: Civ. No. 78-1400 HL; reported at 644 F. Supp. 444 (D.P.R. 1985)
In 1976, Francis D. Shelden created a revocable trust with the Trust Company of the Virgin Islands (TCVI) as trustee and himself as lifetime beneficiary; after Shelden removed TCVI in 1978, the trust's protector, L. Bennett Young, named himself and The Detroit Bank and Trust Co. (later Comerica Bank-Detroit) successor co-trustees. TCVI refused to account or to turn over the assets, and in December 1977 about $1.7 million in trust securities had been moved out of the trust, with the proceeds routed through entities controlled by TCVI's director, Adam Starchild. After trial, the court held that TCVI breached its fiduciary duty by failing to keep accounts, failing to render statements when the beneficiary and the protector requested them, denying the successor trustee and protector access to its books, failing to account annually to the income beneficiary, and opposing its own removal. Finding that the transfers were made "by false pretense, false representation and actual fraud," and because the defendants never accounted, the court held TCVI and Starchild jointly and severally liable for the full present value of the original trust assets, $2,974,380, plus interest from July 21, 1978. Relying on Puerto Rico Civil Code rules on bad-faith possession and unjust enrichment, it also held that the entities that received the diverted funds with notice of their source held them for the trust. An earlier ruling in the same case, Shelden v. Trust Co. of the Virgin Islands, Ltd., 535 F. Supp. 667 (D.P.R. 1982), had allowed the successor trustees to continue the suit.
2. Narváez Maldonado v. Banco Popular de Puerto Rico
Court: Puerto Rico Court of Appeals, Panel III · Date: June 22, 2015 · Docket: KLCE201500641 (trial court: KPE2012-1448, San Juan)
Hospital Damas and Fundación Damas created the Damas Self Insurance Trust Fund in 1986 to meet the financial-responsibility requirement that Law 4 of 1986 imposed on health-care institutions, and Banco Popular became its trustee in 1992. In 2012, a medical-malpractice claimant who had settled with the hospital sued to remove Banco Popular as trustee and to require it to account for its administration. An earlier Court of Appeals panel dismissed that suit in 2012 without prejudice so the claim could be pursued before the Insurance Commissioner, but in 2013 the Commissioner concluded that it had no authority to remove the trustee, appoint a successor or terminate the trust. In this 2015 decision, the Court of Appeals held that the earlier dismissal had worked as a stay pending the administrative process rather than as a final judgment, so the trial court could resume the case, and that the claimant had standing because the trust existed to pay malpractice claims against the hospital. The court affirmed the trial court's order continuing the proceedings and did not decide whether Banco Popular breached any duty. It applied the former Civil Code articles on removal of trustees (since repealed by Act 219-2012) because they were in force when the trust was created and the suit was filed.
3. Rivera Nieves v. Rivera Flores (Sucn.)
Court: Puerto Rico Court of Appeals, Panel VIII · Date: February 21, 2020 · Docket: KLAN201901394 (trial court: D AC2017-0566, Bayamón)
In July 2014, Monserrate Rivera Flores and Aida Luz Nieves Matos created the Fideicomiso La Familia by public deed to protect the family's poultry business and the land that served it, naming their three children as equal beneficiaries; both settlors died later that year. Their son Ángel Luis Rivera Nieves sued to recover a Naranjito property he claimed as his own and to have both the trust and an earlier eviction judgment in the trust's favor declared void, arguing that the trust ended when his parents died. The trial court dismissed his complaint with prejudice on collateral-estoppel grounds, also dismissed the trust's counterclaim, and ordered him to pay $10,000 in attorney's fees. The Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the trust's validity and the title to the property had already been decided between the same parties in earlier cases, including a 2016 order finding that the trust "continúa vigente," so those findings were conclusive even though the causes of action differed. The decision does not address any claim that the trustees mismanaged or failed to account for trust assets.
4. Blanco Ramos v. Blanco Ramos
Court: Puerto Rico Court of Appeals, Panel VIII · Date: November 2, 2021 · Docket: KLAN202100221 (trial court: C AC2015-1626, Arecibo)
In 1997, Dr. Pedro Blanco Lugo and Aura Ramos Selva, the only shareholders of Doctor's Center, Inc., created a trust funded with $1,000 and 121 shares of the company to keep the Manatí hospital operating and to benefit their three children, with Dr. Blanco Lugo as trustee and their son Carlos named as one of the substitute trustees. In 2001, Dr. Blanco Lugo carried out a distribution that valued the company at $26.5 million and gave Carlos common shares and his two sisters preferred shares; in 2003, at the request of his sister Carla Blanco Ramos, the remaining Class A preferred shares were transferred to her and her sister. In 2015, Carla sued Carlos for breach of fiduciary duty, alleging that the company had been worth at least $45.5 million and that he had ignored the trust's mandate of equal distribution. Applying the former Civil Code trust articles (the trust predated Act 219-2012), the Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment for Carlos: the trust ended in 2003 when its last assets were distributed, Carlos never accepted the role of substitute trustee, and "ninguna responsabilidad civil puede imponerse al apelado Blanco Ramos por incumplir un deber que nunca le asistió." The court added that any challenge to the distribution had to be brought against the person serving as trustee when it was made, within the limitations period for personal actions. It declined to disturb the trial court's $10,000 award of attorney's fees for temerity.
5. Rivera Nieves v. Fideicomiso de la Familia
Court: Puerto Rico Court of Appeals, Panel X · Date: November 30, 2021 · Docket: KLAN202100515 (trial court: BY2020CV02199, Bayamón)
In the fourth case between the parties over the Fideicomiso La Familia (see No. 3), Ángel Luis Rivera Nieves again sought to have the trust declared void or terminated, this time attributing its end to Hurricanes Irma and María, and asked for an accounting and for liquidation of the trust's assets. The trial court granted the trust's motion for summary judgment and the other defendants' Rule 10.2 motion to dismiss, dismissed the case with prejudice, and imposed $5,000 in attorney's fees for temerity. The Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the case met, "por no decir que excede," the requirements of res judicata in its collateral-estoppel form, because the trust's existence and continuity and the trustees' acts of administration had already been decided between the same parties. The court did not rule on an accounting claim on the merits; it treated the issue as foreclosed by an earlier final partial judgment declaring that the trustees had performed acts of administration and accounting under the Trust Act.
Summary Notes
- Refusing to account is itself a breach, and it can be costly. In Detroit Bank, the court treated each of these as a breach of fiduciary duty: failing to keep and render accounts, denying access to the trust's books, and resisting removal. Because the trustee never accounted, the trustee and its director were held liable for the full value of the trust assets plus interest.
- Diverted trust assets can be followed. In the same case, the court held that entities that took trust funds knowing where they came from held those funds for the trust, under Puerto Rico unjust-enrichment principles.
- Fiduciary duties belong to whoever actually serves as trustee, and they end with the trust. In Blanco Ramos, a named substitute trustee who never accepted the role owed no fiduciary duty, and no duty survived the trust's termination. Claims about a distribution must be brought against the trustee who made it, and on time.
- Courts enforce finality in trust disputes. In the Rivera Nieves litigation, the Court of Appeals twice held that issues already decided could not be relitigated: the trust's validity and continuity, the title to trust property, and the trustees' administration. It affirmed judgments that included attorney's-fee awards against the beneficiary who kept refiling ($10,000 in 2020 and $5,000 for temerity in 2021). Blanco Ramos likewise left in place a $10,000 fee award for temerity.
- Removal and accounting claims go to court. In Narváez Maldonado, the Insurance Commissioner said it had no authority to remove the trustee of a hospital self-insurance trust. The Court of Appeals let the removal-and-accounting suit go forward in the Court of First Instance and held that a malpractice claimant whom the trust exists to pay had standing to bring it.
- Which law applies depends on when the trust was created. For trusts created before Act 219-2012, the courts applied the former Civil Code trust articles (Blanco Ramos, Narváez Maldonado). The 2014 Fideicomiso La Familia was treated as a separate, autonomous estate under Act 219-2012 (Rivera Nieves).
Concerned About Trustee Misconduct?
If you suspect a trustee has breached their fiduciary duties or mismanaged trust assets, prompt legal action is critical. Attorney Hans Riefkohl at Riefkohl Law has extensive experience with trust litigation and fiduciary duty claims in Puerto Rico.
Schedule a Free Consultation →
Related resources: Puerto Rico Trust Law Guide | Fiduciary Duties Guide | Trust Law Article Series