Motor Vehicle Warranty Regulation and Dealer Financial Responsibility

Puerto Rico Law Controversies

When a Financed Car Sale Is Rescinded for an Unremedied Defect, the Dealer Repays the Loan and the Lender Refunds the Buyer's Payments

Prepared March 15, 2026

Court: Tribunal de Apelaciones de Puerto Rico

Date: February 27, 2026

Citation: Ruiz Valle v. Ebenezer Auto, LLC; Popular Auto, LLC, 2026 WL 710265 (TCA)

Summary of Relevant Facts

On August 4, 2023, Rosa E. Ruiz Valle purchased a used 2022 Mitsubishi vehicle with 13,800 miles from Ebenezer Auto, LLC. The vehicle was financed through Popular Auto, LLC, with Banco Popular de Puerto Rico (BPPR) as the financing entity. Shortly after purchase, the vehicle developed a noise in the left side panel. The manufacturer denied warranty coverage because the vehicle had been in a collision; Ebenezer attempted repairs, but the noise persisted. She took the vehicle to Caribbean Auto for evaluation. An inspection on August 12, 2024, confirmed the vehicle had traveled 19,702 miles and showed multiple defects.

Procedural Background

In December 2023, Ruiz Valle filed a complaint with DACO alleging breach of warranty and improper disclosure of the defect. DACO issued a resolution declaring the complaint valid and ordering contract resolution and return of payments. BPPR, as assignee of the financing contract, was served and took part in the DACO proceedings, although it did not appear at the hearing. The dealer appealed.

Main Controversies

The main controversies were: (1) whether DACO had jurisdiction over the financing entity BPPR and could hold it solidarily liable with the dealer; (2) whether the dealer had a reasonable opportunity to repair the defect before contract rescission was warranted; and (3) how financial responsibility should be distributed among the dealer, the financing entity, and the consumer when a financed vehicle purchase is rescinded under Puerto Rico's Motor Vehicle Warranty Regulation (Regulation No. 7159).

Position of the Parties

Ebenezer Auto argued that DACO's resolution was procedurally deficient for failing to include the financing entity and that the financial distribution was erroneous. Ruiz Valle argued the defect was never remedied despite notice, warranting full contract rescission and return of all payments.

Holding or Decision

The Tribunal de Apelaciones modified the DACO resolution. It held that BPPR (successor to Popular Auto) must refund to Ruiz Valle all monthly payments she made, and that Ebenezer Auto must relieve her of the remaining loan balance by paying BPPR the full amount BPPR advanced under the loan. Ruiz Valle returns the vehicle.

Reasons for the Decision

The court emphasized that appellate courts give broad deference to administrative agency decisions, limited to situations where the agency acted arbitrarily, irrationally, or illegally, or where decisions lack substantial evidence. The court found that DACO had jurisdiction over BPPR, which had been served and had litigated before the agency, but that, under Otero Rivera v. USAA Fed. Savs. Bank, 214 DPR 473 (2024), solidarity is not presumed and could not be imposed on the financing entity; each party must return what it received. Under the Motor Vehicle Warranty Regulation (Regulation No. 7159), the vendor must provide warranty coverage for vehicles up to certain mileage thresholds, and when the vendor cannot or will not correct the defect, contract rescission is appropriate. The court modified the financial obligation distribution to ensure each party bore appropriate responsibility, distinguishing between the dealer's obligation to make the consumer whole and the financing entity's obligation to return payments already collected.

Need Legal Assistance in Puerto Rico?

Riefkohl Law provides experienced legal counsel across a wide range of practice areas. Explore our resources:

Call (787) 236-1657 or schedule a consultation to discuss your legal needs.

Previous
Previous

Act 60 for Software Companies: How to Qualify for Puerto Rico’s 4% Tax Rate

Next
Next

Dual-Tracking Protections Under Federal Regulation X and Puerto Rico Law 169